When mail is not signed
The usual causes, in the order to check them.
5 minute readUpdated 6 November 2026
On this page (6)
Check Logs first
Settings → Mail log shows every message the relay handled. If the message you sent is there, the "Result" column says why it was not signed. If it is not there at all, the message never reached the relay, which points at the Exchange connector or the transport rule.
Message is in Logs but not signed
- No rule matched: the rules did not cover this sender, direction or recipient. Check the rule’s "who" and "when".
- Unknown sender: the mailbox is not in the synced directory. Press "Sync users".
- No free seat: every seat you bought is in use. Add seats or free one under Users.
- Excluded from signatures: an admin excluded this person under Users.
- Reply, skipped: the rule is set to sign the first email only.
- Encrypted or calendar: these message types are passed through untouched by design.
- Subscription needed or tenant not connected: fix on Billing or the Microsoft 365 page.
Message never reaches the relay
On the Microsoft 365 page run the Exchange health check. It confirms the outbound and inbound connectors and the transport rule exist and are enabled. A rule disabled by an admin, or a connector deleted during a tidy-up, is the usual cause. "Connect Exchange" again recreates them.
If the health check is green and mail still bypasses the relay, look for another transport rule in Exchange with a higher priority that stops processing, and for mail sent from a client that submits directly rather than through Exchange Online.
Signed, but lands in spam or bounces
Signed mail goes back through Microsoft 365 and leaves from Microsoft’s servers, so your SPF record only needs to include Microsoft (include:spf.protection.outlook.com), not Geco. Check that, and that DKIM is set up in Microsoft 365 for the domain. If your own people’s mail lands in Junk, run the Exchange health check.
Looks wrong in one mail client
Outlook on Windows ignores some CSS that other clients honour. Use the builder’s elements rather than pasted HTML where possible, keep images under about 600 pixels wide, and avoid background images. Preview as a colleague whose details are longest to catch wrapping.
Still stuck
Email support@gecosign.com with the workspace name, the sender address and the time of a test message, and we will look at the relay’s record of it. We reply within five working days, usually much sooner.