How to use a different signature for new emails and replies

How to set one Outlook signature for new emails and a shorter one for replies and forwards in new Outlook, classic Outlook, Outlook on the web and Mac.

5 minute readBy the Geco Signatures team

Outlook lets you choose one default signature for new messages and a different one for replies and forwards. Create two signatures, usually a full one and a short one, then set each as a default. In new Outlook and Outlook on the web this is under Settings > Accounts > Signatures. In classic Outlook it is File > Options > Mail > Signatures, under Choose default signature. On a Mac it is Settings > Signatures, under Set default signature.

The Outlook app on iPhone and Android has no separate reply signature. It uses the same one for everything.

On this page (8)
  1. Why use a shorter signature for replies
  2. How to set a reply signature in new Outlook and Outlook on the web
  3. How to set a reply signature in classic Outlook
  4. How to set a reply signature in Outlook for Mac
  5. How to switch signature in a single reply
  6. Where per-person settings fall short
  7. Doing this for a whole company
  8. Questions people ask

Why use a shorter signature for replies

A full signature on a new email is useful. The person may not know you, and it gives them your role, number and website. In a long thread, though, repeating the logo and every detail on each reply adds clutter and pushes the conversation down the screen. Each copy of the logo can also show up as another attachment in some mail apps.

A common approach is a full signature for new messages and a two or three line signature for replies. For Pam Beesly at the Michael Scott Paper Company, that might look like this.

  • New messages. Pam Beesly, Office Administrator, Michael Scott Paper Company, 01632 960123, michaelscottpaper.com and the company logo.
  • Replies and forwards. Pam Beesly, Michael Scott Paper Company, 01632 960123.

How to set a reply signature in new Outlook and Outlook on the web

  1. Select Settings (the gear icon).
  2. Select Accounts > Signatures.
  3. If you have more than one account, choose the one you want to set up.
  4. Select Add signature, name it “Full” and create your full signature. Select Save.
  5. Select Add signature again, name it “Reply” and create the short version. Select Save.
  6. In the default signature options at the bottom, choose Full for new messages and Reply for replies and forwards.
  7. Select Save.

Because new Outlook and Outlook on the web share these settings, you only need to do this once for both. If you use classic Outlook version 2303 or later with a Microsoft 365 mailbox, signatures you create there roam to these apps too.

How to set a reply signature in classic Outlook

  1. Go to File > Options > Mail > Signatures.
  2. In the E-mail account drop-down, choose your account.
  3. Select New, name the signature “Full” and type it under Edit signature.
  4. Select New again, name it “Reply” and type the short version.
  5. Under Choose default signature, set New messages to Full and Replies/forwards to Reply.
  6. Select OK.

If you don’t want any signature on replies, set Replies/forwards to (none). You can still add one to a particular reply by hand.

How to set a reply signature in Outlook for Mac

  1. On the Outlook menu, select Settings.
  2. Under Mail, select Signatures.
  3. Create a full signature and a short one with the add button.
  4. Under Set default signature, choose your account.
  5. Set For new messages to the full signature and For replies or forwards to the short one.
  6. Close the Signatures window.

Outlook for Mac keeps its own signatures, so set this up on each Mac you use. In legacy Outlook for Mac the same options are called New messages and Replies/forwards under Choose default signature. Our Outlook for Mac signature guide has more detail.

How to switch signature in a single reply

Sometimes you want the full signature on a reply, for example when you’re replying to someone new who was copied in. You can swap it in that one message.

  • New Outlook and Outlook on the web. Select the old signature in the message and delete it, then on the Insert tab select Signature and choose the one you want. If you’re replying in the reading pane and can’t see the Insert tab, select Open in new window first.
  • Classic Outlook. Delete the old signature, then select Signature on the ribbon and choose another. If you’re replying in the reading pane and can’t find it, select Pop Out to open the reply in its own window.
  • Outlook for Mac. Delete the old signature, click where you want the new one, then select Signature on the ribbon and choose it.

Where per-person settings fall short

For a small team, asking everyone to create two signatures and set the defaults works well. It takes a few minutes, and the result is tidier threads.

Across a company it becomes hard to keep consistent. Everyone has to create both signatures and set the defaults, on each computer that doesn’t share roaming signatures. Phones can’t have a separate reply signature at all. People decide for themselves what goes in the short version, so some replies carry a full signature and others carry only a first name.

Admins sometimes try an Exchange mail flow rule instead. A rule can add text to every message, but it appends it at the end of the email. In a reply that means below the whole quoted thread, far from the newest message, and it can’t easily tell a first message from a reply. Our guide to mail flow rule signatures explains the trade-offs.

Doing this for a whole company

Geco Signatures applies signatures on the server, with rules that can give the first message in a conversation the full signature and later replies a shorter one. In replies the signature sits directly under the sender’s newest text, above the quoted thread, rather than at the bottom. It works the same for mail sent from phones, which have no reply signature setting of their own. The signatures are designed once and each person’s details come from Microsoft 365.

Questions people ask

Can Outlook use a different signature for replies?

Yes. In every desktop and web version of Outlook you can set one default signature for new messages and a different one for replies and forwards. The iPhone and Android app uses one signature for both.

Why doesn’t my signature appear when I reply in Outlook?

The reply default is probably set to none. Set a signature for replies and forwards in Settings > Accounts > Signatures in new Outlook, or under Choose default signature in classic Outlook.

Where is the Signature button when replying in new Outlook?

It is on the Insert tab. When you reply in the reading pane the Insert tab isn’t shown, so select Open in new window first.

Should my reply signature include a logo?

Usually not. A short text signature with your name, company and phone number keeps threads tidy, while the full signature with logo goes on new messages.

How to use a different signature for new emails and replies | Geco Signatures